Culture & History Digital Journal, Vol 2, No 1 (2013)

Another History for Another Psychiatry. The Patient’s View


https://doi.org/10.3989/chdj.2013.021

Rafael Huertas
Instituto de Historia, CCHS-CSIC, Madrid, Spain

Abstract


This article aims to summarise, in the first instance, some of the historiographical trends which have built a “critical” history of psychiatry from the 1960s onwards. Thereafter, it will demonstrate, with suitably significant examples, how methods and discourses were being refined and updated, before reaching a proposal for a new cultural history of psychiatry and subjectivity. In our analysis, special emphasis is placed on the “patient's view”. This renders necessary the task of identifying little consulted sources, such as the writings of the mad, and the incorporation of interdisciplinary hermeneutic tools, including, most notably, those taken from cultural studies and, in particular, written culture. Finally, it will offer a reflection on the epistemic role that this historiographical approach could play in the construction of new ways of understanding mental health, such as that represented by so-called post-psychiatry.

Keywords


historiography; cultural history; psychiatry; madness; subjectivity; cultural studies

Full Text:


HTML PDF XML

References


Alexander, Franz and Selesnick, Sheldon (1967) The History of Psychiatry: an evaluation of psychiatric thought and practice from prehistoric times to the present. George Allen & Unwin, London.

Álvarez, José María (2008) La invención de las enfermedades mentales. Madrid, Gredos.

Álvarez, Raquel; Huertas, Rafael and Peset, José Luis (1993) "Enfermedad mental y sociedad en la Europa de la segunda mitad del siglo XIX". In Asclepio, 45 (2): 41-60. PMid:11640561

Álvarez-Uría, Fernando (1983) Miserables y locos. Medicina mental y orden social en la Espa-a del siglo XIX. Barcelona, Tusquet.

Artières, Philippe (1998) Clinique de l'écriture. Une histoire du regard médical sur l'écriture. Institut Synthélabo (col. Les Empêcheurs de penser en rond), Paris.

Artières, Philippe (2000) Le livre des vies coupables. Autobiographies de criminels (1896-1909). Albin Michel, Paris.

Barfoot, Michael and Beveridge, Allan (1990) "Madness at crossroads: John Home's letters from the Royal Edinburgh Asylum, 1886-87". In Psychological Medicine, 20: 263-284. http://dx.doi.org/10.1017/S0033291700017591 PMid:2192382

Basaglia, Franco (editor), (1968) L'Istituzione negata. Rapporto da un ospedale psichiatrico. Nuovo Politecnico, Torino. PMid:5240065

Bercherie, Paul (1980) Les fondements de la clinique. Histoire et structure du savoir psychiatrique. Navarin, Paris. PMid:11634519

Bernardi, Alberto de (1982) Follia, psichiatria e società. Istituzioni manicomiali, scienza psichiatrica e classi sociali nell'età moderna e contemporanea. F. Angeli, Milano.

Berridge, Virginia (2007) "Public health activism: lessons from history?". In British Medical Journal, 335:1310-1311. http://dx.doi.org/10.1136/bmj.39399.612454.AD PMid:18156243 PMCid:PMC2151155

Berrios, German (1996) The History of Mental Symptoms. Descriptive Psychopathology since the Nineteenth Centuty. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge. http://dx.doi.org/10.1017/CBO9780511526725 PMCid:PMC486678

Berrios, German (2011) Hacia una nueva epistemología de la psiquiatría. Polemos, Buenos Aires.

Beveridge, Allan (1998) "Life in the Asylum: Patients letters from Morningside, 1873-1908". In History of Psychiatry, 9: 431-469. http://dx.doi.org/10.1177/0957154X9800903602 PMid:11623612

Bracken, Patrick and Thomas, Philip (2001) "Postpsychiatry: a new direction for mental health". In British Medical Journal, 322: 724-727. http://dx.doi.org/10.1136/bmj.322.7288.724 PMid:11264215 PMCid:PMC1119907

Bracken, Patrick and Thomas, Philip (2005) Postpsychiatry: Mental Health in a Postmodern World. Oxford University Press, Oxford. http://dx.doi.org/10.1093/med/9780198526094.001.0001

Butterfield, Herbert (1931) The Whig Interpretation of history. G. Bell, London.

Butterfield, Herbert (1950) "The historian and the history of science". In Bulletin of the British Society for the History of Science, 1: 49-57.

Campos, Ricardo (2010) "Leer el crimen. Violencia, escritura y subjetividad en el proceso Morillo (1882-1884)". In Frenia, 10: 95-122.

Campos, Ricardo and Huertas, Rafael (2008) "Los lugares de la locura. Reflexiones historiográficas en torno a los manicomios y su papel en la génesis y desarrollo de la psiquiatría". In Arbor, 184 (731): 471-480.

Castel, Robert (1977) L'ordre psychatrique. L'âge d'or de l'aliénisme. Minuit, Paris. PMCid:PMC431784

Castillo, Antonio and Sierra, Verónica (editors), (2005) Letras bajo sospecha. Escritura y lectura en centros de internamiento. Trea, Gijón.

Colina, Fernando (1999) "Prólogo". In La invención de las enfermedades mentales by José María Álvarez. 1st ed. DOR, Madrid, pp. 15-20.

Colina, Fernando (2007) "Locas letras (variaciones sobre la locura de escribir)". In Frenia, 7: 25-59.

Condrau, Flurin (2007) "The Patient's View Meets the Clinical Gaze". In Social History of Medicine, 20 (3): 525-540. http://dx.doi.org/10.1093/shm/hkm076 http://dx.doi.org/10.1093/shm/hkm076

Dain, Norman (1980) Clifford W. Beers: advocate for the insane. University of Pittsburgh Press, Pittsburgh.

Dain, Norman (1994) "Psychiatry and Anti-Psychiatry in the United States". In Discovering the History of Psychiatry, edited by Micale, Mark and Porter, Roy, Oxford University Press, New York/Oxford, pp. 415-444.

Davis, Kerry (2001) "Silent and Censured Travellers? Patients' Narratives and Patients' Voices: Perspectives on the History of Mental Illness since 1984". In Social History of Medicine, 14 (2): 262-292.

Deutsch, Albert (1937) The Mentally ill in America. A History of Their Care and Treatment from Colonial Times. Doubleday, New York.

Dörner, Klaus (1969) Burger und Irre. Zur Sozialgeschichte und Wissenschaftsgeschichte der Psychiatrie. Europäische Verlagsanstalt, Frankfurt.

Dowbiggin, Ian (1991) Inheriting Madness: Professionalization and psychiatric knowledge in nineteenth-century France. University of California Press, Berkeley CA.

Ellenberger, Henri (1970) The Discovery of the Unconscious. The History and Evolution of Dinamic Psychiatry. Basic Books, New York.

Foucault, Michel (1961) Folie et déraison. Histoire de la folie à l'âge classique. Plon, Paris. PMid:13695832

Foucault, Michel (1966) Les mots et les choses. Une archéologie des sciences humaines. Gallimard, Paris. PMid:5942193

García Díaz, Celia and Jiménez Lucena, Isabel (2010) "Género, regulación social y subjetividades. Asimilaciones, complicidades y resistencias en torno a la loca (El manicomio de provincial de Málaga, 1920-1950)". In Frenia, 10:123-144.

Gauchet, Marcel (1994) "À la recherché d'une autre histoire de la folie". In Dialogue avec l'insensé, edited by Swain, Gladys, Gallimard, Paris, pp. IX-LVIII.

Goffman, Erving (1961) Asylums. Essay on the Social Situation of Mental Patients and Other Inmates. Doubleday, New York.

Goffman, Erving (1968) Stigma: Notes on the Management of Spoiled Identity. Pelican Books, London.

Goldstein, Jan (1984) "Foucault among the sociologist: The disciplines and the history of the professions". In History and Theory, 23: 170-192. http://dx.doi.org/10.2307/2505005

Goldstein, Jan (1987) Console and Classify. The French psychiatric profession in the nineteenth century. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.

Goldstein, Jan (1994) "Foucault and the post-revolutionary self: The uses of Cousinian pedagogy in nineteenth-century France". In Foucault and the Writing of History, edited by Goldstein, Jan, Blackwell, Oxford, pp. 99-115.

Goldstein, Jan (2005) The Post-Revolutionary Self: politics and psyche in France. 1750-1850. Harvard University Press, Cambridge MA.

Guha, Ranajit and Spivak, Gayatri (editors), (1988) Selected Subaltern Studies. OUP, Oxford.

Hacking, Ian (1986) "Making Up People". In Reconstructing Individualism: Autonomy, Individuality in Self Investigation Thought, edited by Heller, T., Stanford University Press, Stanford, pp. 161-171.

Hacking, Ian (1994) "Looping Effects of Human Kinds". In Causal Cognition: A Multidisciplinary Approach, edited by Sperber, D., Premarck, D. and Premarck, A. J., Clarendon Press, Oxford, pp. 351-383.

Hacking, Ian (1995) Rewriting the Soul: Multiple Personality and the Sciences of Memory. Princenton University Press, Princenton.

Hacking, Ian (1998) Mad Travelers. Reflections on the Reality of Transient Mental Illnesses. University Press of Virginia, Charlottesville & London. PMCid:PMC1051282

Hacking, Ian (2004) "Between Michel Foucalt and Enving Goffman: between discours in the abstract and face-to-face interaction". In Economy and Society, 33 (3): 277-302. http://dx.doi.org/10.1080/0308514042000225671

Harding, Sandra (1998) Is Science Multicultural? Postcolonialism, Feminism, and Epistemologie. Indiana University Press, Bloomington.

Hervey, Nicholas (1986) "Advocacy or folly: The Alleged Lunatic's Friend Society, 1845-63". In Medical History, 30: 254-275. http://dx.doi.org/10.1017/S0025727300045701

Hobsbawm, Eric (1971) "From Social History to the History of Society". In Daedalus, 100 (1): 20-45.

Huertas, Rafael (2001a) "Historia de la psiquiatría, ¿por qué?, ¿para qué?: Tradiciones historiográficas y nuevas tendencias". In Frenia, 1 (1): 9-36.

Huertas, Rafael (2001b) "Las historias clínicas como fuente para la historia de la psiquiatría. Posibles acercamientos metodológicos". In Frenia, 1 (2): 7-32.

Huertas, Rafael (2002) Organizar y persuadir. Estrategias profesionales y retóricas de legitimación de la medicina mental espa-ola (1875-1936). Frenia, Madrid. PMCid:PMC166561

Huertas, Rafael (2008) Los laboratorios de la norma. Medicina y regulación social en el Estado liberal. Octaedro, Barcelona.

Huertas, Rafael (2010) "Locura y subjetividad en el nacimiento del alienismo. Releyendo a Gladys Swain". In Frenia, 10: 11-28.

Huertas, Rafael (2011) "En torno a la construcción social de la locura. Ian Hacking y la historia cultural de la psiquiatría". In Revista de la Asociación Espa-ola de Neuropsiquiatría, 31: 437-456.

Huertas, Rafael (2012) Historia cultural de la psiquiatría. (Re)pensar la locura. La Catarata, Madrid.

Hunter, Richard and Macalpine, Ida (1961) "John Thomas Perceval (1803-1876), patient and reformer". In Medical History, 6: 391-395. http://dx.doi.org/10.1017/S0025727300027745

Jaeger, Marcel (1981) Le désordre psychiatrique. Des politiques de la santé mentale en France. Payot, Paris. PMCid:PMC1805396

Jones, Kathleen (1955) Lunacy, Law and conscience, 1744-1845: The Social History of the Care of the Insane. Routledge & Kegan Paul, London.

Kaufmann, Doris (1995) Aufklärung, Selbsterfahrung und die "Erfindung" der Psychiatrie in Deutschland, 1770-1850. Vandenhoeck & Ruprecht, Göttingen.

Lantéri-Laura, Georges (1972) "La chronicité dans la psychiatrie française moderne". In Annales ESC, 27: 548-568.

Lantéri-Laura, Georges (1979) Lecture des perversions. Histoire de leur appropriation médicale, Masson, Paris.

Lantéri-Laura, Georges (1991) Les hallucinations. Masson, Paris.

Lantéri-Laura, Georges (1998) Essais sur les paradigmes de la psychiatrie moderne. Editions du Temps, Paris.

Laverack, Glenn (2013) Health Activism: Foundations and Strategies. Sage Publications, London. PMCid:PMC3655658

Lefebvre, Georges (1924) Les Paysans du Nord pendant la Révolution française. C. Robbe, Lille.

Lehmann, Heinz and Ban, Thomas (1997) "The history of the psychopharmacology of schizophrenia". In Canadian Journal of Psychiatry, 42: 152-162. PMid:9067064

Levín, Santiago (2012) "Historia de la psiquiatría, aquí y ahora, ¿desde qué concepción de la historia?". In Temas de Historia de la Psiquiatría Argentina, 32: 6-11.

Lewin, Kurt (1946) "Action research and minority problems". In Journal of Social Issues, 2 (4): 34-46. http://dx.doi.org/10.1111/j.1540-4560.1946.tb02295.x

Lilienfeld, Scott and Marino, Lori (1999) "Essentialism revisited: evolutionary theory and the concept of mental disorder". In Journal of Abnormal Psychology, 108: 400-411. http://dx.doi.org/10.1037/0021-843X.108.3.400 PMid:10466262

López-Mu-oz, Francisco; Álamo, Cecilio and Cuenca, Eduardo (2002) "Aspectos históricos del descubrimiento y de la introducción clínica de la clorpromazina: medio siglo de psicofarmacología". In Frenia, 2 (1): 77-107.

Lyons, Martin (2012) "New Directions in the History of Written Culture". In Culture & History Digital Journal 1(2): e007.

Marx, Otto (1992) "What is the history of psychiatry? II". In History of Psychiatry, 3: 293-301. http://dx.doi.org/10.1177/0957154X9200301102

Matusevich, Daniel and Pieczanski, Pedro (2012) "¿Qué es la post-psiquiatría? Escenarios y encrucijadas de la psiquiatría actual". In Epistemología y psiquiatría. Relaciones peligrosas, edited by Vaschetto, Emilio, Polemos, Buenos Aires, pp. 79-96.

Mignolo, Walter (2003) Historias locales, dise-os globales: colonialidad, conocimientos subalternos y pensamiento fronterizo. Akal, Madrid.

Molinari, Augusta (2005) "Autobiografías de mujeres en un manicomio italiano a principios del siglo XX". In Letras bajo sospecha. Escritura y lectura en centros de internamiento, edited by Castillo, Antonio and Sierra, Verónica, Trea, Gijón, pp. 379-400.

Mora, George (1980) "Three American Historians of Psychiatry: Albert Deutsch, Gregory Zilboorg and George Rosen". In Essays in the History of Psychiatry, edited by Wallace, E.R. and Pressley, L.C., William S. Hall Psychiatric Institute, Columbia (South Carolina), pp. 1-21.

Morman, Edward (1994) "George Rosen and the History of Mental Illness", In Discovering the History of Psychiatry, edited by Micale, Mark and Porter, Roy, Oxford University Press, New York/Oxford, pp. 95-111.

Morrison, Linda (2005) Talking Back to Psychiatry: The Psychiatric Consumer/Survivor/Ex-Patient Movement. Routledge, London.

Moscoso, Javier (2001) "Realidad o elaboración de la enfermedad mental". In Frenia, 1 (2): 131-144.

Moyn, Samuel (2009) "The assumption by man of his original fracturing: Marcel Gauchet, Gladys Swain, and the history of the self". In Modern Intellectual History, 6 (2): 325-341. http://dx.doi.org/10.1017/S147924430900211X

Novella, Enric (2007) "Construcción y fragmentación del sujeto psicológico". In Archivos de Psiquiatría, 70 (1): 9-24.

Novella, Enric (2009) "De la historia de la psiquiatría a la historia de la subjetividad". In Asclepio, 61 (2): 261-280. http://asclepio.revistas.csic.es/index.php/asclepio/article/view/293/289 [accesed 17/April/2013].

Novella, Enric (2010) "La política del yo: ciencia psicológica y subjetividad burguesa en la Espa-a del siglo XIX". In Asclepio, 62 (2): 453-482. http://asclepio.revistas.csic.es/index.php/asclepio/article/view/475/477 [accesed 17/April/2013]. PMid:21305795

Novella, Enric (2011) "La medicina de las pasiones en la Espa-a del siglo XIX". In Dynamis, 31 (2): 453-474. http://dx.doi.org/10.4321/S0211-95362011000200010

Parker, Gordon; Hadzi-Pavlovic, Dusan and Eyers, Kerrie (1996) Melancholia: A disorder of movement and mood: A phenomenological and neurobiological review. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge. http://dx.doi.org/10.1017/CBO9780511759024

Peset, José Luis (1983) Ciencia y marginación. Sobre negros, locos y criminales. Crítica, Barcelona.

Peset, José Luis (1993) Las heridas de la ciencia. Junta de Castilla y León, Salamanca.

Pigeaud, Jackie (1981) La maladie de l'âme. Étude sur la relation de l'âme et du corps dans la tradition médico-philosophique antique. Les Belles Lettres, Paris.

Porter, Roy (1985) "The Patient's View: Doing Medical History from below". In Theory a Society, 14 (2): 175-198. http://dx.doi.org/10.1007/BF00157532 PMid:11618212

Porter, Roy (1987) A Social History of Madness. Stories of the Insane. Weidenfeld and Nicolson, London.

Porter, Roy and Micale, Mark (1994) "Introduction: Reflections on Psychiatry and Its Histories". In Discovering the History of Psychiatry, edited by Micale, Mark and Porter, Roy, Oxford University Press, New York/Oxford, pp. 3-36. PMid:8180753

Postel, Jacques and Allen, David (1994) "History and Anti-Psychiatry in France". In Discovering the History of Psychiatry, edited by Micale, Mark and Porter, Roy, Oxford University Press, New York/Oxford, pp. 384-414.

Reaume, Geoffrey (2009) Remembrance of patients past. Patients Life at the Toronto Hospital for the Insane, 1870-1940. University of Toronto Press, Toronto. PMCid:PMC2683210

Rigolí, Juan (2001) Lire le délire. Aliénisme, rhétorique et littérature en France au XIXe siècle. Fayard, Paris.

Ríos, Andrés (2004) "Locos letrados frente a la psiquiatría mexicana a inicios del siglo XX". In Frenia, 4 (2): 17-35.

Romme, Marius and Escher, Sandra (editors), (1993) Accepting Voices. MIND Publications, London.

Romme, Marius and Escher, Sandra (2000) Making Sense of Voices: A Guide for Mental Health Professionals Working with Voice-Hearers. MIND Publications, London. PMid:11071491

Rosen, George (1968) Madness in Society. Chapters in the Historical Sociology of Mental Illness. University of Chicago Press, Chicago.

Rosen, George (1970) "Mental Disorder, Social Deviance and Culture Pattern: Some Methodological Issues in the Historical Study of Mental Illness". In Psychiatry and Its History: Methodological Problems in Research, edited by Mora, George and Brand, Jeanne, Charles C. Thomas, Springfield, pp. 172-194.

Rothman, David (1971) The Discovery of the Asylum. Social Order and Disorder in the New Republic. Little Brown, Boston.

Sass, Louis (1992) Madness and Modernism: Insanity in the Light of Modern Art, Literature and Thought. Basic Books, New York.

Schipperges, Heinrich (1985) Homo patiens. Zur Geschichte des kranken Menschen, Piper Verlag, München-Zurich.

Scull, Andrew (1979a) "Moral treatment reconsidered: some sociological comments on an episode in the history of British Psychiatry". In Psychological Medicine, 9: 421-428. http://dx.doi.org/10.1017/S0033291700031962 PMid:384444

Scull, Andrew (1979b) Museums of Madness. The Social Organization of Insanity in Nineteenth Century England. Allen Lane, London.

Scull, Andrew (1991) "Psychiatry and its historians". In History of Psychiatry, 2: 239-250. http://dx.doi.org/10.1177/0957154X9100200701 PMid:11613223

Semelaigne, René (1930-32) Les Pionniers de la psychiatrie française avant et après Pinel. Baillière, Paris.

Shorter, Edward (1997) A History of Psychiatry, From the Era of the Asylum to the Age of Prozac. John Wiley & Sons, New York.

Shorter, Edward and Healy, David (2008) Shock therapy: a history of electroconvulsive treatment in mental illness. Rutgers University Press, New Brunswick.

Staeuble, Irmingard (1991) "Psychological man and human subjectivity in historical perspective". In History of the Human Sciences 4: 417-432. http://dx.doi.org/10.1177/095269519100400306

Stolberg Michael (2003) Homo Patiens. Krankheits- und Körpererfahrung in der Frühen Neuzeit. Böhlau Verlag, Köln/Weimar/Wien.

Swain, Gladys (1977) Le sujet de la folie: Naissance de la psychiatrie. Privat, Toulouse.

Swain, Gladys (1994) Dialogue avec l'insensé. Gallimard, Paris.

Szasz, Thomas (1961) The Myth of Mental Illness: Foundations of a Theory of Personal Conduct. Paul B. Hoeber, New York.

Tardits, Annie (2002) "Une lecture inédite de l'aliénisme. À propos de Lire le délire de Juan Rigolí". In Essaim. 10: 165-171.

Thompson, Edward (1963) The making of the English working class. Victor Gollancz, London.

Tsou, Jonathan (2007) "Hacking on the Looping Effects of Psychiatric Classifications: What Is an Interactive and Indifferent Kind?". In International Studies in the Philosophy of Science, 21 (3): 329-344. http://dx.doi.org/10.1080/02698590701589601

Wadi, Yonissa (2009) A história de Pierina: subjetividade, crime e loucura. EDUFU, Uberlândia.

Wakefield, Jerome (1999) "Mental disorder as a black box essentialist concept". In Journal of Abnormal Psychology, 108: 465-472. http://dx.doi.org/10.1037/0021-843X.108.3.465 PMid:10466270

Weymans, Wim (2009) "Revisiting Foucault's Model of Modernity and Exclusion: Gauchet and Swain on Madnes and Democracy". In Thesis Eleven, 98 (1): 33-51.

Zilboorg, Gregory (1941) A History of medical Psychology. Norton, New York.




Copyright (c) 2013 Consejo Superior de Investigaciones Científicas (CSIC)

Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.


Contact: historia.digital@cchs.csic.es

Technical support: soporte.tecnico.revistas@csic.es