Scylla and charybdis 2.0: reconstructing colonial Spanish American territories between metropolitan dream and effective control, historical ambiguities and cybernetic determinism


  • Werner Stangl University of Graz, Historical Institute, Economic and Social History



Historical GIS, WebGIS, vernacular GIS, database design, colonial administration, socioeconomic history, bourbon reforms


This paper tries to outline the main methodological obstacles that have to be addressed and overcome at reconstructing late colonial Spanish American territories and their development by means of a historical Geographic Information System (HGIS). First we try to show how historians with a broad gamut of research interests could profit from such a territorial HGIS infrastructure for that time and space. In a second step we try to show how certain aspects complicate the task. These include: vernacular concepts of territory (definitions of what actually is a “province”); the quality, focus, and methods of data gathering in contemporary geographic descriptions, cartographies, and other sources; the lack of definition of interior borders; the sometimes contradictory divisions in military, civil, ecclesiastical, and financial districts; as well as the general discrepancy between administrative control and political claims. And as if these aspects were not enough, there are the competing claims on territories of sovereignty in Latin America, which —by applying the uti possidetis juris principle— are largely based on colonial territories. In the last part, we outline the basic concept of a spatial database which tries to respond to the raised issues and furthermore incorporates a chronological axis. The model is illustrated by giving the example of the Puno-region.


Download data is not yet available.


Acevedo, Edberto Óscar (1992) Las intendencias altoperuanas en el virreinato del Río de La Plata. Academia Nacional de la Historia, Buenos Aires.

Alcedo, Antonio de (1786-89) Diccionario geográfico-histórico de las Indias Occidentales ó América [...]. Manuel González, Madrid.

Alcedo, Antonio de and Thompson, George A. (1812-15) The Geographical and Historical Dictionary of America and the West Indies. Carpenter, London.

Alcedo Ugarte y Herrera. Dionisio de (1741) Compendio histórico de la provincia, partidos, ciudades, astilleros, ríos y puerto de Guayaquil. Manuel Fernández, Madrid.

Alcedo Ugarte y Herrera, Dionisio de (1915) Descripción geográfica de la real Audiencia de Quito, edited by González Palencia, C. A. Hispanic Society of America, Madrid.

Archivo Nacional [de Chile] (1953) Censo de 1813. Imprenta Chile, Santiago.

Baker, Alexi (2013) "Vernacular GIS: Mapping Early Modern Geography and Socioeconomics". In History and GIS: Epistemologies, Considerations and Reflections, edited by Von Lünen, Alexander and Travis, Charles. Springer, New York: 89-110.

Bertuch, F.J. (editor), (1819) Neue allgemeine geographische (und statistische) Ephemeriden. Geographisches Institut, Weimar.

Bueno, Cosme (1764-1778) Descripción de las provincias de los Obispados y Arzobispados del Virreinato del Perú. Oficina de la Calle de la Coca, Lima. [accessed 5/March/2014].

Carvallo y Goyeneche, Vicente (1875-76) Descripción histórico-jeográfica del reino de Chile, edited by Gay, Claudio. La estrella de Chile, Santiago. [accessed 11/March/2014].

Crespo Solana, Ana and Alonso García, David (editors) (2012) Selforganizing Networks and GIS Tools. Cases od Use for the Study of Trading Cooperation (1400-1800), Special Issue of Journal of knowledge Management, Economics and Information Technology, June : 402.

Crespo Solana, Ana (2013) "La Historia geográficamente integrada y los Sistemas de Información Geográfica (SIG): concepto y retos metodológicos". Tiempos modernos: Revista Electrónica de Historia Moderna, 26. [accessed 15/February/2014].

D'Efilippo, Valentina and Ball, James (2013) The Infographic History of the World. Collins, London.

Dragicevic, S.; Marceau, D.J. and Marois, C. (2001) "Space, Time, and Dynamics Modeling in Historical GIS Databases: A Fuzzy Logic Approach". Environment & Planning B: Planning & Design, 28.

Gerhard, Peter (1972) A guide to the historical Geography of New Spain. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.

Gerhard, Peter (1979) The Southeast Frontier of New Spain. Princeton University Press, Princeton.

Gerhard, Peter (1982) The North Frontier of New Spain. Princeton University Press, Princeton.

Gregory, Ian N. (2002) "Mapping British Population History". In Past Time, Past Place. GIS for History, edited by Kelly Knowles, Anne. ESRI, Redlands: 117-130.

Gregory, Ian N. (2003) A Place in History. A guide to using GIS in historical research. Oxbow, Oxford.

Gregory, Ian N. (2004) "Approaches to using national historical GISs to analyse long-term geographical change": talk given at the Research Methods Festival at Southhampton University, July 2nd, 2004. programme/Fri/pm/C/documents/gregory.doc [accessed 25/February/2014].

Gregory, Ian N. (2007) Historical GIS: Technologies, Methodologies, and Scholarship. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.

Guitarte, Guillermo L. (1995-6) "La traducción inglesa del Diccionario de Alcedo y su vocabulario de americanismos". Boletín de Filología, XXXV: 179-207.

Herrera Ángel, Marta (2001) "Las divisiones político-administrativas del virreinato de la Nueva Granada a fines del periodo colonial". Historia crítica (Bogotá), 22: 76-105.

Herrera Ángel, Marta (2006) "Las bases Prehispánicas de la Configuración Territorial de la Provincia de Popayán en el período colonial". Journal of Latin American Geography, 5 (2): 53-73.

Humboldt, Alexandre de (1811) Essai politique sur le royaume de la Nouvelle Espagne, vol. 2. F. Schoell, Paris.

Juarrós, Domingo (1808) Compendio de la historia de la ciudad de Guatemala, 3 vols. Beteta, Guatemala City.

Juarrós, Domingo (1824) A Statistical and Commercial History of the Kingdom of Guatemala, in Spanish America, abbreviated English edition translated by J. Baily. Cowie/Hearne, London.

Kantabutra, Vitit and Owens, J.B. (2013) "Intentionally-Linked Entities: a better database system for representing dynamic social networks, narrative geographic information, and general abstractions of reality". [accessed

Knowles, Anne Kelly (editor) (2002) Past Time, Past Place. GIS for History. ESRI, Redlands.

Knowles, Anne Kelly (2008) "GIS and History". In Placing History: How Maps, Spatial Data, and GIS Are Changing Historical Scholarship, edited by Anne Kelly Knowles. ESRI, Redlands: 1-25.

Knowles, Anne Kelly; Hillier, Amy and Balstad, Roberta (2008) "Conclusion: An Agenda for Historical GIS". In Placing History: How Maps, Spatial Data, and GIS Are Changing Historical Scholarship, edited by Anne Kelly Knowles. ESRI, Redlands: 267-273.

Lacoste, Pablo (2002) "La guerra de los mapas entre Argentina y Chile: una mirada desde Chile". Historia (Santiago), 35: 211-249.

Martí-Henneberg, Jordi (2011) "Geographical Information Systems and the Study of History". Journal of Interdisciplinary History, 41 (1): 1-13.

McMaster, Robert B. et al. (2005), "Reports on National Historical GIS Projects". Historical Geography, 33: 134-158.

Offen, Karl (2011) "La cartografía colonial de Centroamérica y el topónimo 'Mosquito'". Boletín de la AFEHC (Asociación para el Fomento de los Estudios Históricos en Centroamérica), 48.

aff&id=2582 [accessed 12/March/2014].

Peters, Jeffrey N. (2004) Mapping Discord: Allegorical Cartography in Early Modern French Writing. University of Delaware Press, Newark.

Picazo Muntaner, Antoni (2013) "Sistema, redes y mercados en los océanos Índico y Pacífico: un ejemplo de visualización". Tiempos modernos: Revista Electrónica de Historia Moderna, 26. [accessed 15/February/2014].

Porro Gutiérrez, Jesús María (2013) "La política de consolidación de las fronteras hispanas en Suramérica y la cartografía generada". Jahrbuch fu.r Geschichte Lateinamerikas, 50: 55-79.

Robles Domínguez de Maraziegos, Mariano (1813) Memoria histórica de la provincia de Chiapa, una de las de Guatemala. Tormentaria, Cádiz.

Solano, Francisco de (1990) Ciudades hispanoamericanas y pueblos de indios. CSIC, Madrid.

Tanck de Estrada, Dorothy (2005) Atlas ilustrado de los pueblos de indios. Nueva Espa-a, 1800. El Colegio de México, Mexico City.

Tomaszewski Brian M. and Smith, Michael E. (2011) "Polities, territory and historical change in Postclassic Matlatzinco (Toluca Valley, central Mexico)". Journal of Historical Geography, 37: 22-39.

Torre Saavedra, Ana Laura de la (2005) "El fin de las fronteras y el establecimiento de límites en el Septentrión". Jahrbuch fu.r Geschichte Lateinamerikas, 42: 293-319.

Vollmer, Gu.nter (1967) Bevölkerungspolitik und Bevölkerungsstruktur im Vizekönigreich Peru zu Ende der Kolonialzeit (1741- 1821). Gehlen, Bad Homburg vor der Höhe.

Vos, Jan de (1993) Las fronteras de la frontera sur: Rese-a de los proyectos de expansión que figuraron la frontera entre México y Centroamérica. Universidad Juárez Autónoma de Tabasco, Villahermosa.

Zadeh, Lofti A. (1997) "Toward a theory of fuzzy information granulation and its centrality in human reasoning and fuzzy logic". Fuzzy Sets and Systems, 90: 111-127.



How to Cite

Stangl, W. (2015). Scylla and charybdis 2.0: reconstructing colonial Spanish American territories between metropolitan dream and effective control, historical ambiguities and cybernetic determinism. Culture &Amp; History Digital Journal, 4(1), e008.